Digital transition – at the service of citizens

Digital technologies are transforming cities, having a direct impact on local people’s lives. Ensuring safe and secure access to digital services, and placing ordinary people at the centre of the process are key to ensuring that digital transformation leaves no one behind.

Digital technologies are revolutionising the way in which cities are organised, transforming physical realities, social interactions, and technical processes and systems. According to the results of the Eurocities Pulse Mayors Survey, the digital transformation is one of the top three areas where EU funding can make the biggest difference to mayors’ policy objectives in the next five years. Furthermore, thanks to planned investments, such as an earmarking of 20% of funding for digital measures under the EU Recovery plan, over 80% of mayors expect to be able to cover, or partially cover this needed investment in the next five years.

The use of digital tools and applications have a direct impact on people’s lives. Therefore, granting safe and secure access to digital services that represent their interests entails a great responsibility for local governments, and is notably included in one of the top ten priorities listed by mayors for 2023 in the Eurocities Pulse survey.

Digital transformation brings potential benefits for both the administration and residents, such as new opportunities to make services more efficient, enhancing the participation of local people, and enabling data-driven decision making. However, digitalisation also brings interconnected challenges, such as unequal access to infrastructure and digital skills, transparency on data use and data ownership, or ensuring responsible use of artificial intelligence, among others. By placing people at the centre of the digitalisation process, cities can ensure that digital services are responsive to the needs and interests of the local community and reflect societal values, and that the benefits of digital transformation are shared equitably among inhabitants.

Digital technologies are transforming cities, having a direct impact on local people’s lives. Ensuring safe and secure access to digital services, and placing ordinary people at the centre of the process are key to ensuring that digital transformation leaves no one behind.

Digital technologies are revolutionising the way in which cities are organised, transforming physical realities, social interactions, and technical processes and systems. According to the results of the Eurocities Pulse Mayors Survey, the digital transformation is one of the top three areas where EU funding can make the biggest difference to mayors’ policy objectives in the next five years. Furthermore, thanks to planned investments, such as an earmarking of 20% of funding for digital measures under the EU Recovery plan, over 80% of mayors expect to be able to cover, or partially cover this needed investment in the next five years.

The use of digital tools and applications have a direct impact on people’s lives. Therefore, granting safe and secure access to digital services that represent their interests entails a great responsibility for local governments, and is notably included in one of the top ten priorities listed by mayors for 2023 in the Eurocities Pulse survey.

Digital transformation brings potential benefits for both the administration and residents, such as new opportunities to make services more efficient, enhancing the participation of local people, and enabling data-driven decision making. However, digitalisation also brings interconnected challenges, such as unequal access to infrastructure and digital skills, transparency on data use and data ownership, or ensuring responsible use of artificial intelligence, among others. By placing people at the centre of the digitalisation process, cities can ensure that digital services are responsive to the needs and interests of the local community and reflect societal values, and that the benefits of digital transformation are shared equitably among inhabitants.

People at the heart of the digital transformation

Local governments are increasingly committed to user-centric digital services and recognise their benefits for local people, businesses and society. To help cities make user involvement an integral part of digital local government and give local people a more prominent role in developing public services, UserCentriCities was born. This project, which runs from December 2020 to May 2023, supports municipalities to use co-creation in service design and adopt an iterative approach to service delivery that considers people’s needs. Many cities have a digital strategy that is less than three years old according to results gathered by the project, making this an area in which increased city-to-city exchanges can prove invaluable.

To protect digital rights and fight the digital divide, cities need mechanisms, structures, and clear digital rights strategies. Only a handful of local authorities have formal service standards for user-centric service design. And while many local authorities have issued design guidelines for making user-centricity happen, many lack the essential monitoring and enforcement tools to assess their implementation. To track these processes, UserCentriCitie has created a dashboard that will continue to add cities and regions’ systems.

Sharing data for better applications

Data is a basis for our future cities, as it will support a better understanding of our local environments, informing the development of effective policies and efficient delivery of services. For example, mobility data could help avoid urban congestion, and combining building information models with energy consumption data contributes to building local solar communities.

Successfully leveraging the potential of data, however, depends on effectively collecting, accessing, and using data from various sources and owners. For example, cities advocate the development of scenarios in which data held by businesses, such transport or energy data, can be accessed by public authorities not just for public emergencies. Such data is essential for delivering public services, simulating policy interventions and shaping public spaces. The Data Act proposed by the European Commission in February 2022 represents a significant opportunity to support Business-to-Government data sharing, providing conditions for public sector bodies to access data held by private entities.

In support of solid data governance in Europe that includes cities, the European Commission adopted, in December 2022, an implementing act on high-value data sets (open data and publicly available datasets), offering cities access to high-value datasets from other public sector organisations. Additionally, the Data Governance Act provides a framework to clarify the roles and responsibilities of different actors in data sharing ecosystems.

Although a harmonised European framework for access to and re-use of data might be beneficial for local governments, the value of data will only be unlocked if collaborations arise in which data on several levels and from various sources flows freely and where value is distributed fairly.

The question is how you apply technology to deliver wider benefits. How can it be used to do things differently and shape our local policies? How do we embed it into institutional cultures and get people more familiar with using it to help them do their jobs? How do we make sure as much as possible is published openly?

– Jamie Cudden, Smart City Lead at Dublin City Council

Unlocking the power of data

The preparatory action Data Space for Smart and Sustainable Cities and Communities (DS4SSCC) is working to lay the foundation for the creation of a data space for smart communities, as an enabler of the EU Green Deal and Sustainable Development Goals.

It provides a coordinated starting point for public, private, and individual stakeholders to contribute and use data, aligned with European values and policies. The project aims to create a blueprint for the data space for smart communities, including recommended actions for standardisation, business models and strategies for running data spaces, and a vision for the federation of platforms.

Eurocities is leading the work on co-creating data governance schemes to guide practices and interactions with stakeholders (e.g. industry, academia, civil society, etc.) in the cities’ data spaces.

Using data to improve cities

Cities use data to better understand local’s needs, preferences, and behaviour, informing policy making and assessing its impact on cities’ infrastructure, sustainability, and liveability. Munich, for example, gathers 3D geographical data that contributes to climate and environmental protection, security measures, better mobility, and improving public participation. Barcelona uses data in a digital twin model to analyse the audience of sports events and public transport users’ patterns. This also works to optimise the water distribution network and where to place primary care centres and public libraries.

Digital transformation is one of the greatest challenges cities will face in the following years.

– Alessandro Ghinelli, Mayor of Arezzo

Harnessing insights for better decision making

Local Digital Twins are digital replicas of a city or community’s physical assets, processes, and systems. These replicas are linked to all relevant data, including information about the surrounding environment. They rely on AI algorithms, data analytics, and machine learning to generate digital simulation models that can be updated and adapted to reflect changes in their physical counterparts. They are different from other data analysis and visualisation approaches because they can integrate data from many sources in real time and assess future scenarios through advanced simulations.

To promote their use, the Living-in.EU community has set up a forum on Local Digital Twins. Thanks to the collaboration between city, regional and national experts, the Living-in.EU comunity aims to identify existing use cases and potential interest from different groups across the EU.

Placed into urban contexts, digital twins help smart cities reassess their urban planning, transforming how cities are designed, monitored and managed. To deliver their promises, digital twins require a collaborative and interactive environment. Therefore, in line with the objectives of the EU digital agenda, the Eurocities taskforce on digital twins worked during 2022 to promote a culture of digital twins. The taskforce allowed cities to share experiences, knowledge, initiatives and best practices, and harmonise their strategies.

But it is not just local governments that can make the most out of data. Local people and civil society can also play a decisive part. For example, the CitiMeasure project, in which Eurocities is a partner, created an interactive digital inventory of citizen science initiatives that collect air quality data to make smart, sustainable, and inclusive cities.

Enhancing the responsible use of artificial intelligence

To unlock the value of all this data, artificial intelligence is frequently applied to process and analyse the information. The increased use of advanced algorithmic systems and AI has a growing impact on society. Cities advocate for a broad definition of AI systems with comprehensive and appropriate regulation, while also calling for precise requirements on the obligations and responsibilities of AI users and providers.

As such, the European proposal for an Artificial Intelligence Act is very relevant for cities. This proposal was initially adopted by the Commission in April 2021, adopted by the European Parliament in May 2023. Depending on the risk classification of an algorithmic system, cities, as users of applications leveraging AI, will have obligations and responsibilities according to the proposal.

Taking a lead on this European legislation, Barcelona, Bologna, Brussels Capital Region, Eindhoven, Mannheim, Rotterdam, and Sofia – based on the example set by Amsterdam and Helsinki – have developed a free-to-use, open-source ‘data schema’ for algorithm registers in cities, published in January 2023. This algorithm transparency standard provides common guidelines for cities to publish information about the algorithms that they use and what choices have been made in their development. Transparency supported by local algorithm registers empowers local people and puts them at the heart of future developments in digital transformation.

The digital transition must be just. We don’t want technology for the sake of technology, but to make more impactful policies.

– Laia Bonet, Deputy Mayor of Barcelona