Reading Time: 9 minutes

Integrating for a Better Europe

In a world marked by increasing globalisation and population mobility, the integration of migrants and refugees into local communities is a pressing concern for cities worldwide. Across Europe, cities play an essential role in providing sustainable integration pathways and creating welcoming societies for all.

Embracing, welcoming, integrating, and co-living approaches are imperative and should be supported and implemented through collaboration across different levels of government. In this year’s Eurocities Pulse Mayors Survey, mayors listed migration, and especially integration of Ukrainian refugees, among their top challenges from 2023.

Yet, cities often highlight their difficulties in securing EU funding through national programmes when they encounter political roadblocks, for instance, when national and local governments belong to different political parties.

In Eurocities migration policy paper, cities call for future-oriented integration policies and for the various EU funding streams to be made more accessible to reinforce local social services and coordinate civil society’s response to welcoming refugees. Moreover, EU funding calls could be better tailored to realities on the ground, for instance, by supporting existing structures instead of focusing on innovative integration approaches.

In a world marked by increasing globalisation and population mobility, the integration of migrants and refugees into local communities is a pressing concern for cities worldwide. Across Europe, cities play an essential role in providing sustainable integration pathways and creating welcoming societies for all.

Embracing, welcoming, integrating, and co-living approaches are imperative and should be supported and implemented through collaboration across different levels of government. In this year’s Eurocities Pulse Mayors Survey, mayors listed migration, and especially integration of Ukrainian refugees, among their top challenges from 2023.

Yet, cities often highlight their difficulties in securing EU funding through national programmes when they encounter political roadblocks, for instance, when national and local governments belong to different political parties.

In Eurocities migration policy paper, cities call for future-oriented integration policies and for the various EU funding streams to be made more accessible to reinforce local social services and coordinate civil society’s response to welcoming refugees. Moreover, EU funding calls could be better tailored to realities on the ground, for instance, by supporting existing structures instead of focusing on innovative integration approaches.

Over two years of war in Ukraine

Since the beginning of Russia’s illegal war in Ukraine, city level action has been pivotal in ensuring the integration of Ukrainian people. This responsibility persists despite the strain on local budgets, but cities’ work is most impactful when matched with appropriate financial support.

Within the EU-funded UNITES initiative, municipalities collaborate on co-designing integration strategies with migrant communities established in local environments. Thanks to UNITES, cities with limited prior experience in integration strategies, such as Oulu or Prague, have successfully implemented methods to integrate Ukrainians.

UNITES supports Prague’s efforts to collaborate with Ukrainian-led organisations, providing psychological support, integration advice, and conflict prevention activities. Additionally, the city is working on building a base for communication and feedback with migrant communities. Under UNITES, the Finnish city of Oulu hired a Ukrainian psychologist to offer mental health support to newcomers and gather feedback to ascertain the needs of the Ukrainian community.

According to the Council of the European Union, more than 4.2 million people from Ukraine benefited from the Temporary Protection Directive as of November 2023. While the Directive has undoubtedly yielded positive outcomes, local authorities express concerns about its implications and impact on Ukrainians residing in their cities once it expires.

Thanks to UNITES, we could see what is working in other cities and metropolitan areas and how to coordinate. This collective strength of European cities is essential, particularly given the political individualism that exists in some parts of Europe.

– Céline Deslattes, Vice-President of Grenoble Metropole in charge of employment, insertion, youth and the reception of refugees

In response to this issue, Eurocities and its network of more than 200 member cities from across Europe are calling with one voice for the EU and national governments to decide on the next steps required to ensure the residence and protection status of Ukrainian migrants. In addition to these immediate concerns, cities are confronted with an emerging new challenge: transitioning from emergency responses to a more sustainable, long-term integration strategy.

That’s the case of Bratislava. Since early 2022, Bratislava has taken in 34,865 refugees, representing 7% of the city’s population, including more than 10,100 children. As a result, the share of migrants and refugees increased from 8% in 2020 to 14% in 2022. Nowadays, the city employs data collection and analysis to devise a strategic framework for better inclusion of individuals with foreign backgrounds at the local level.

The conflict in Ukraine and the need for long-term strategies provided inspiration for CONSOLIDATE, which kicked off in March 2024. CONSOLIDATE, funded through the EU Asylum, Migration and Integration Fund, works with twelve cities for more effective support in labour market integration for refugees and other newcomers. It also offers support mechanisms for refugees to live autonomously in self-managed housing and one stop shops that are designed to be accessible places for coordinated service provision for all newcomers.

Adding to this support, local authorities continue to advocate for better access to integration funding in the current funding period of 2021-2027 and the forthcoming EU budget.

CONSOLIDATE

With the recent surge in Ukrainian refugee arrivals echoing the challenges of the past, CONSOLIDATE has emerged as a project that responds to the needs of cities in the field of migration, building on the knowledge acquired in recent projects (CONNECTION and UNITES).

Working hand in hand with 12 partner cities, CONSOLIDATE is at the forefront of pioneering policy pilots in:

  • Transforming labour market integration for refugees and newcomers.
  • Empowering refugees with housing autonomy support.
  • Streamlining one-stop shops for efficient and accessible support services.

Partner cities are Athens, Cluj-Napoca, Dortmund, Fuenlabrada, Ghent, Gothenburg, Lublin, Milan, Nantes, Sofia, Vienna, and Zagreb.

Integration for all

To build cohesive asylum and migration policies that integrate local realities, cities must be included as equal partners in multi-level policy discussions. This includes not only the integration of Ukrainian beneficiaries via temporary protection measures, but also the protection of all refugees.

People settling in European cities hail from diverse nationalities and cultures. All migrants and refugees need access to residence and work permits, housing, education, medical care and social welfare. However, migrant communities suffer from different types of exclusion, including labour market obstacles, lack of participation in the public sphere, the digital gap or language barriers.

Cities work to overcome those obstacles. For instance, Madrid has forged a partnership with the Spanish Commission for Refugee Assistance, among other NGOs, to foster the development of green skills among 135 third-country migrants and applicants for international protection, with a particular focus on women.

Rotterdam endeavours to address digital exclusion through its Teatime initiative, in which women from Turkish backgrounds gather to acquire digital skills. Similarly, Espoo developed a study to gather feedback on migrant trust in the local government and, based on it, adapt or create better public services.

Under UNITES, Grenoble Alpes Metropole has created the a platform through which refugees provide feedback on policies and actions affecting their lives in the city. The insights gained through city-to-city collaboration in these projects offer valuable lessons to the development of EU migration policy.

In Zaragoza, the House of Cultures facilitates cultural exchanges and ensures migrant communities’ needs are recognised and addressed. Managed by elected associations – two migrant-led, two social entities and one representative of the Roma community – the House of Cultures ensures representation from civil servants, public administration and civil society associations.

To get to know the structure of the city administration, and to ensure the participation of migrant communities, Dusseldorf has involved a group of nine people from migrant communities and will train them for outreach to migrant communities.

Connecting, uniting, consolidating

Cities call on the EU and its member states to monitor the outcomes of the New Pact that, once implemented, could undermine human rights standards and European values. In the Eurocities manifesto – A better Europe starts in cities – Eurocities calls on the European institutions to support cities in embracing refugees of all backgrounds and guarantee the non-discrimination and safety of individuals fleeing their countries.

As articulated in the Eurocities Migration policy paper cities, civil society and other stakeholders should be consulted by EU member states when developing their national action plans to implement the new legislation on the ground.

The paper also underscores the imperative to uphold the universal right to asylum, affirming that the EU should ensure equal access to rights and protection for all refugees in Europe, regardless of their origins and identity, no matter the colour of their skin, their gender, sexual orientation or religion.

In brief, cities must be closely involved in the EU and national responses to receiving refugees. Eager to amplify their contributions to European and national governance, cities stand ready to offer expertise and practical insights in reception efforts while facilitating the exchange of invaluable knowledge. Input from cities is paramount to developing policies that foster more open and inclusive societies where everyone feels welcome regardless of background.

As the city administration, we want to work together with civil society to develop a vision in which Dortmund is anchored in people’s minds as a ‘city of neighbourhoods.’ A vision that gives rise to a collective identity with which all citizens of the city can identify. A city where it doesn’t matter where you come from, but where you want to go.

– Thomas Westphal, Mayor of Dortmund

Recent EU policy developments: The New Pact on Asylum and Migration

On April 10, 2024, the European Parliament endorsed the New Pact on Asylum and Migration.

The Migration and Asylum Pact comprises new and updated regulations governing migration and establishing a unified asylum system within the EU. It aims to offer a holistic strategy concerning critical EU policies on migration, asylum, border control, and integration. Civil society stakeholders have been critical of the legislative files as they fear potential human rights violations.